IMO, a muddled aphorism does not a joke make. So I had a stab at a couple rewrites of today’s joke. Please rate, critique, comment, and let me know your favorite. And let me see the best jokes YOU can whip up!







IMO, a muddled aphorism does not a joke make. So I had a stab at a couple rewrites of today’s joke. Please rate, critique, comment, and let me know your favorite. And let me see the best jokes YOU can whip up!







Comments are closed.
💝Panel 1: Cranky says, “I’M TRYING TO ORDER NEW BATTERIES FOR MY DIGITAL WRISTWATCH.”
💝Panel 2: Cranky says, “BUT THE CUSTOMER SERVICE PERSON I’VE BEEN TALKING TO JUST ASKED ME TO MARRY HER…”
💝Panel 3: Pam says, “Dad, that’s ComicBookHarriet on Son of Stuck Funky. Say yes! Say yes!”
💝💜💖🫂🌺💐🌹
The first one. Also, a juxtaposition doesn’t a joke make either.
9/24: The impression I end up getting is that we’re looking at what hoarders think of people who don’t see the point of clutter…or a small boy angry at Mommy for wanting him to get rid of his stash. If Peter Cadaldi can divest, so can Tom Batiuk.
I like the TikTok one. It fits the strip, and made me laugh!
I like the first one. Short, sweet, topical without being political.
Here’s my version:
QgsLlMb.png (511×253)
And that damned WordPress (or maybe Imgur) has changed how it works again. The link will take you to the image.
WordPress needs to stop mucking with stuff! I just hosted the image here.
Thank you. I appreciate it.
I like the last two best.
Here’s mine: https://imgur.com/a/pTpAoV0
DO NOT REDEEEM!!!
Got the reference!
here’s an edit of mine
Fun facts involving the Sonic.exe universe
Damn, the Sonic lore is complex.
The fact that the Tails Doll, a more than minor unlockable character in the widely ignored and generally unloved (silly and overproduced soundtrack aside) Sega Saturn foot racing game Sonic R, became a Sonic horror fanfiction lore icon is a testament to the remarkable creativity of (and tremendous amount of free time available to) the online Sonic fan community.
Oh the internet rabbit holes you fall down because you are one of the small handful of people who bought Sonic R and actually wanted to try and beat it…
I played the original Sonic The Hedgehog on my old Sega Genesis when I was in college. I thought it was a lot of fun. But man, I just cannot imagine caring enough to know who all the side characters in all the offshoots are.
But I also play Immactulate Grid for fun, and most of my answers are taken from my photographic memory of 1980s baseball cards. And you’ve all seen me gush about Pac-Man. So maybe what you’re obsessive about is a function of when you were born?
a sequel to the above image:
regarding the list of names in panel 3
All surpass Batiuk’s attempt (of course), but CBH’s first one gets my vote.
NEWS ITEM: Sister Jean, the elderly nun/basketball superfan who came to prominence during Loyola-Chicago’s surprising tournament run in 2018, has officially retired from her ministerial roles at the university due to health concerns. She is “no longer able to be present on campus.”
Sister Jean is the same age as Ed Crankshaft.
At some point, actors become too old to insure too.
I believe that’s why William Demarest replaced William Frawley on “My Three Sons.”
And some think it was because Frawley didn’t know a habeas from a corpus!
Yep.
Today’s Crankshaft
Ed: All of them. Not only that, I’m gonna price them at $450 per issue on FleaBay!
9/25: Batiuk just blundered into another too old to worry mess.
Also, isn’t Ed way too old to be insured?
When it comes to Ed Crankshaft’s insurability, his age is the least of his concerns.
Like the fact that his driving instructor yelled BANZAI at Pearl Harbor…..
Today’s corny joke is actually pretty solid, I thought, but the punchline is underplayed and lands too softly. A stand-up comic with the right timing could make underplaying this punchline work, but it is a stronger bit in comic strip form if delivered with either genuine and obtuse irritation (as if they actually tried to get a deer that hit them to provide insurance information), or by a character who is a known cut-up.
“They never have insurance.”
That’s what the punchline needed to be. When Crankshaft just says “no insurance”, it’s not clear what doesn’t have insurance. The deer? Himself? The school system? Why wouldn’t the school system have insurance? Why is that a problem anyway, when he’s driving a publicly-owned vehicle in his offical capacity? It’s not his responsibility to pay for bus repairs. What is he even talking about?
The punchline just needed a little clarity, and it would have worked fine. But this is the kind of writing mistake Tom Batiuk always makes. He thinks he’s being subtle and clever when he’s just being pointlessly vague.
Today’s Crankshaft
Now we’re back in the Centerville Bus District office
I think it’s possible to mine some humor from the premise that a “universal” remote requires a Very Special Battery, though the premise is weakened by the fact that (as any Plugger with a basket full of “universal” remotes that control everything except the device you bought it to control can tell you) nearly all remotes (including all “universal” ones, at least in my experience) use either AA or AAA batteries, and (as any Plugger with a big box of the Wrong Size can tell you) whichever size you have in the cupboard will the the size that doesn’t fit the remote. (Hey, look, I just made two Plugger panels here).
But, in classic Batty style, he drops the premise in panel two. In panel three, where there should be a punch line, he gives us a meaningless word salad that manages to be not a joke, a pun, a malaprop, or any other form of humor, and completely unrelated to the setup in panel two. This is Prime Batty.
The word “universal” really defeats the joke. If this was some obscure imported European TV, or even a fancy TV from the past, it might make sense for the remote to run on some obscure watch battery. (Which wouldn’t even be that difficult to find anymore.)
It’s yet another example of how Batiuk just stuffs words into the balloons without thinking about what they imply. And how he acts like it’s still 1986.
And today, Comics Curmudgeon called the strip out for exactly this.
“His dumb addled wordplay is supposed to be full of accidental polysemy, or should at least sound like it makes sense at first but upon examination doesn’t quite. This is just a wrong word that sounds like the right word!”
Alternate third panel to CBH’s second strip: “Shh! You’re not supposed to know about the hen’s teeth until I finish my experiments to genetically modify chickens into dinosaurs!”
Nah. That would require Batty to know that some beaked dinosaurs also had teeth.
Anyway, with “ICE 6”, we get the thrilling conclusion to Batiuk’s…
Oh, wait. He didn’t post the last strip. Gosh, I wonder why? I’m sure it has nothing to do with his assertion that he was posting the story due to “current events”, yet the finale showed the ICE agents as just regular decent folks who love themselves some Montoni’s pizza. (Actually… I honestly can’t say why Batiuk didn’t post it. I mean, it COULD be because of how far off from “current events” it would make him look, but… it’s not like he normally demonstrates that level of self-awareness, so who even knows?)
(Also, that thing went on for FIVE WEEKS, not counting the “Adeela gets her driver’s license” story. Guess “stories shouldn’t last more than three weeks” doesn’t count when you’re making desperate award bait. Not that there was anything close to five weeks of story there, just lots of idiocy, illogic, and padding.)
(Amazingly, he DID fix the Flash Fridays for #343, so at least he managed to do something right.)
I did enjoy what i guess is the forward to Strike Four!. I always said he should stick with the Cranky/Baseball connection for continuity, audience appreciation and just the small-town Americana of it all. I wonder why he stopped?
“I get how my partner in cartooning on Crankshaft, Chuck Ayers, is a huge baseball fan…”
oh
Not just consecutive strips… but technically consecutive panels.
Magnificent, Davis… Simply magnificent.
No, no, Andy, it’s “How are your grandson, Max, and his partner, Hannah, making out running the old Valentine theater, where they only showed The Phantom Empire until it closed down, became a strip club, and was bought out by Hollywood star Mason Jarre as a money laundering operation and put them back in charge for reasons inexplicable to man?” Come on, man, exposition is everyone’s job, and there’s clearly room to cram more words in that panel. Sheesh.
(Hannah is Max’s Generic Trophy Blonde’s name, right?)
“Hannah is Max’s Generic Trophy Blonde’s name, right?”
Correct
My thinking was that Crank would reply with “Which grandson? The grown up one running the theater or my other grandson that’s the son of my grandson?” Since he seems to be allergic to the phrase “great-grandson” these days.
This speaks to a problem: Batiuk somehow contrives to make all the things that appeal to him sound even more boring than they actually are.
Today’s Crankshaft
Ed: Somehow they’ve lost even more money when they shown the third Starsuck Jones movie.
If you build it and only one weird, out-of-touch person wants it, they won’t come.
Batiuk is at it again with the leaden moralizing.
Today’s Crankshaft
I hope that next week wont be another week long “Most Boringest Interview Ever” because those storylines with Batton and Skip are
Cue Bathack yelling JINX.
9/28: Let’s have another doddering old simpleton strip.
Flash Fridays #344 is up, and… man, this is some peak Batiuk right there.
https://tombatiuk.com/komix-thoughts/flash-fridays-the-flash-344-april-1985/
So for those playing along at home, we’re still in “The Trial of the Flash” (and will be for the next six issues, until the series ends). Kid Flash has been called by the prosecutor to testify.
The issue then segues into ANOTHER flashback/reprint. Almost the entire issue is recycled material, representing Flash’s thoughts about Kid Flash. Batiuk even describes the original material as encompassing maybe two minutes of time. AND HE LOVES IT.
The seventh-to-last issue, and they did a fill-in reprint? And you’re PRAISING it?
Y’know, for some reason, Davis’ “art” on Crankshaft makes a LOT more sense now. (Not to mention that week we saw Girl Les wandering around the places Batiuk used to live. Or, really, and of the other examples of blatant padding we could name.) I really don’t think we could denigrate him any more than his own words can.
It’s people like him that made someone make a smart remark about Marvel coming up with something called Last Week’s Comics because the Marvel zombies would buy them too.
Why not? After all, the Marvel zombies bought up multiple series called Marvel Zombies, didn’t they?
And they still don’t realize that they’re the joke.
It’s a bit odd to me, because TB very rarely reused artwork in Act II and in much of Act III when doing his incessant Act I flashbacks. There was so much opportunity, but instead he redrew panel after panel of sepia-toned Act I material.
Perhaps the fact that Ayers penciled most of those strips made it easier… and/or TB’s artwork having drifted significantly from even late Act I by the late 90s made it seem necessary (in contrast, the occasional flashbacks to huge-head early Luann don’t seem to bother Greg Evans much)… but still, he did once put in the extra work he is now having an artist not do and also praising another for not doing. Strange indeed.
Today’s Crankshaft
(Crankshaft suddenly Gmod ragdolls onto the ground)
Like I said, somebody jinxed it because it’s Stereo Author Inserts.
Today’s Crankshaft
How I feel whenever it’s Most Boringest Interview Ever Week and Whiny Manbaby Jeff Murdoch decides to walk into the storyline to discuss useless shit with Batton:
To paraphrase The Amazing Colossal Man’s Col. Glenn Manning, “What sin could a comic strip readership commit in a single lifetime to bring this upon themselves?”
The problem is that neither of them realize how they make a subject more boring than life.
There was a KID Flash? The mind boggles. Was his best friend a Norwegian named Ole Jimmson, The Flash’s Pal?
Tomorrow: “Well, I’ll be! If it isn’t my triplegänger, Les Moore! Sure hope Putin doesn’t choose this exact moment to drop a nuke on Centerville!”
(But kudos to Bats for remembering the umlaut on Doppelgänger.
Sincererly,
B.D.I. DiNytpicker.)
Like I said on Arcamax, the plot sickens.