Yes! This story is actually continuing! It’s not an April Fool’s prank, I promise you!
BAILIFF: All rise for the Honorable Collis D. Smizer.
JUDGE: As you were. Next up is the much-delayed case 53766673, the Village Booksmith fire. Now, Mr. Moore, do you have proper counsel?

MR. BREEF: I am Amicus Breef, from the law firm of Westview Community College Discount Legal Services. I will be representing the defendant, Les Moore.
JUDGE: Very good. Welcome, Mr. Breef. Our previous session ended in the middle of cross examination. Mr. Flaherty, would you like to continue?
CONTINUED CROSS EXAMINATION
(Les Moore, having duly been sworn in, testifies as follows:)
PROSECUTOR: Mr. Moore, I was asking you if you remembered a student of yours named Eric “Mooch” Myers. This student of yours was found to have started two different fires in 1999: one during homecoming, and a second during an ordinary school day. Eric initially reported that second fire to the authorities, and was called a hero on local TV news for doing so.

PROSECUTOR: Do you remember these incidents?

LES: Yes.
PROSECUTOR: At the time, you yourself noted that Myers was seeking attention. Correct?
LES: Yes.
PROSECUTOR: I believe this is also why you started the Village Booksmith fire. You saw an opportunity to be the hero again, taking a bold stand against a non-existent enemy of literature. And you took full advantage of it.

LES: I would never put my own friends at risk.
PROSECUTOR: But you did. You already testified that you put Lillian McKenzie at risk, despite her being uncomfortable with this whole situation, when safer options were available. You also had Pete Roberts-Reynolds and Mindy Murdoch help you. Plus bookstore employees Amelia and Emily Matthews. You certainly didn’t mind putting any of them at risk! You let these people – your three friends, and two underage girls – worry about a threat that they thought was real. Eric Myers may have been your student, but it seems you learned a lot from him as well.

LES: Well, that’s what it means to be a teacher.
PROSECUTOR (ignoring Les): Which is also why the fire was laughably small. You didn’t want anyone to get hurt, or even for Lillian to suffer much property damage. Which is why you started the fire at the very bottom of the building’s wooden stairs, when copies of Fahrenheit 451, the supposed target of all this, were upstairs. And you knew that, because you just moved them up those stairs yourself!
This fire was so far away from the books that it couldn’t possibly have reached them. And, it was easily visible from the outside, so it would be seen and put out quickly. All of this is consistent with your motive of wanting to set a fire without actually burning anything.
On top of all that, creosote oil is a wood preservative, as well as a fire accelerant. Which would explain your choice of this unorthodox arson catalyst. You might as well have applied fire-resistant wood sealant to Lillian’s staircase before you set it on fire. Do you deny any of this?

LES: You’re proven nothing.
PROSECUTOR: And what of Lillian herself? She flat-out told you she didn’t feel safe, when you were the one she should have been afraid of all along! And you knew that! An elderly single woman who —

LILLIAN McKENZIE: I’m single because–
UNIDENTIFIED VOICE: We know, Lillian!
JUDGE (banging gavel): Order!
(Order is restored.)
PROSECUTOR: Mr. Moore, do you recognize this document?

LES: It appears to be a sales receipt for an online purchase.
PROSECUTOR: And can you tell the court what items were purchased?

LES: It’s– wait, what? You can’t pull this out on me at the last minute!

MR. BREEF: Your Honor, I object! I want to file a subpoena for the evidence!

LES: What?
(A brief, confused pause.)
JUDGE: Mr. Breef, all the evidence has already been presented, and provided to you. Are you suggesting there is a need to subpoena new evidence?
MR. BREEF: Umm…
JUDGE: Overruled. Lack of relevance. The counselor may continue.
PROSECUTOR: Mr. Moore, this document was given to you during discovery, as was all the other evidence, when you were effectively pro se. It was also given to Mr. Breef as soon as he notified my office that he was your new counsel. We have the electronic records to prove this exchange took place. So I will ask you again, Mr. Moore: will you please tell the court what items were purchased in this receipt? You are under oath.

LES: Ummmm, creosote oil, and a copy of the book Lisa’s Story.

LES: But so what? Anybody could have bought those things.
PROSECUTOR: “A” copy of Lisa’s Story? Can you double-check the quantity?

LES: Uh, three.
PROSECUTOR: Three?

LES: Hundred.

LILLIAN (from the audience): Hey!
PROSECUTOR (in full “the defendant is full of shit and I’m about to prove it” mode): Now, who on earth needs to buy 300 copies of the same book? Other than the man who wrote that book, and does frequent public signings of that book?

LES: Maybe the buyer wanted to read it more than once?
(No one laughs.)

LILLIAN: You bastard!
JUDGE: Order! Ms. McKenzie, no more outbursts, or I will ask you to leave.
(Lillian sits down.)
PROSECUTOR: Can you also tell me the quantity of the creosote oil?

LES: 20 liters.
PROSECUTOR: And who is the purchaser on this invoice?

LES (scanning the document): Well, I can already see it’s not me, it’s the…

LES: Lisa’s Legacy Foundation.
PROSECUTOR: And are you the director of the Lisa’s Legacy Foundation?

LES: Yes.
PROSECUTOR (blatantly hamming it up now): Why does a charitable organization need creosote oil at all? Much less 20 liters of it?

LES: Is it too late to change my plea?
April fools! It really wasn’t a prank. I let this story sit way too long, and I thought it would be a nice surprise to finally deliver the goods. My re-telling of The Burnings will resume on a more regular basis soon. Really. Also, last year’s prank was going to be hard to top.
Past installments of the story were:
- Prologue 1: If The Burnings Were A Movie, You’d Walk Out. Let’s Write A Better One.
- Prologue 2: Murder In The Burnings: The Minor Suspects
- Prologue 3: Murder In The Burnings: The Major Suspects
- Chapter 1: Testimony Of Nate Green
- Chapter 2: Testimony Of Arson Investigator
- Chapter 3: Further Testimony Of Blaise Ashcomb
- Chapter 4: Testimony Of Skip Rawlings
- Chapter 5: Testimony Of Police Investigator
- Chapter 6: Testimony Of Student
- Chapter 7: Cross Examination Of Defendant
- Chapter 8: Further Cross Examination Of Les Moore
Today’s installment was Chapter 9. Stay tuned for Chapter 10!











































