Leaf it to Me

Man, I only realized when I saw a comment over at GoComics that the dumb political arc meant we got no Pizza Box Monster this Halloween. Of course Batiuk would toss a precious young gag (young relatively speaking) on the pile to rot in order to get his prestige arc out by election day.

I’m not one to disrupt tradition though! So of course I got my traditional killer headcold of harvest that has me in such a befuddled brain fog that I can’t even begin to parse out the pen buying nonsense of this week. I almost thought that ‘Allen’ looked like he could be Batton’s son, and wondered if we’re finally getting another Brian insert finally, to replace Dead St Lisa.

While my head meat recovers from bad juju, I decided to slack off with another young tradition. The 1977 edition of EXISTENTIAL LEAVES.

I don’t even have thought juice left to make funny captions. Please, you in the comments, do my job for me!

You Presume Too Much

For Summer Moore, the future seemed to be bright. She’d managed to return from a knee injury and lead the Lady Scapegoats to a presumably gutsy championship win while sick as a dog. The strength of her performance in high school as well as help from Coach Bushka led to her and Keisha getting offered scholarships from the greatest of all universities that experienced National Guard related tragedies in the Akron metro area in 1970. With high school now behind her, readers were left wondering at just what Tom Batiuk would be able to do with Summer as a young adult attempting to find a life for herself on her own. Unfortunately for these theoretical (as in likely nonexistant) readers, it’ll be a slow slide into oblivion but not before she gets to play a somewhat central role in one more story before getting shipped off to Purgatory U.

Graduation of course included a Dead Lisa Tape where the nazgul nag implored her daughter to “follow her heart.” Summer informs dear old dad that she intends do just that…

…by deciding to fire off Zanzibar’s Gun and take that trip to Africa that Les won back at the Save Our Sports raffle.

Summer knows that her father is a doughy, out of shape, middle aged geek so she’s also brought in Bull to help whip Les into shape for the big climb, much to his chagrin.

Les also gets some additional “help” in the form of Crazy Harry lending him a bunch of old Tarzan comics.

I’m sure they’d be useful if Les encounters situations with which he’d need to play role of an outdated and culturally questionable jungle adventure hero and given the things Batty has done that wouldn’t have been outside the realm of possibility. But fortunately (or unfortunately) it won’t go in that direction so the comics are as useless as Harry.

Batty does decide, however, to take a brief detour from the training in order to dedicate a week of Les’ daughter and his bride-to-be going through an old yearbook and laughing at what a loser he used to be.

To steal an old Mitch Hedberg joke, he still is a loser but he used to be one too.

Still leading up to the main event, we get some more training and what I believe is the very first continuity snarling appearance of the rotting, barely alive version of Ed Crankshaft in Act III.

The Moores also go shopping for some gear and Les takes the opportunity to tell Summer that he will be an annoying jackass the entire trip, possibly out of revenge for Summer making him go on it. Summer presumably is now hoping that he suffers from one of any number of deaths on the hike.

With the preparations done, Cayla takes Les and Summer to the airport having decided not to go with them. She says it’s because she “doesn’t do camping” but for all we know she was probably looking forward to getting rid of Les for a few weeks; or maybe I’m putting more stock into her character than she deserves.

After an inane week dedicated to Funky naming his new car, father and daughter have arrived in Tanzania and Les immediately endears himself to their local guide by making good on his threat of incessantly performing his Dr. Livingston shtick. We know that this story was based on an actual trip Batty took so I can only pray for the sanity of the other hikers that the real deal was nowhere near as annoying as his fictional counterpart.

Summer is already over this crap.

There’s also other people with them on this trip of course, most notably Dan who will exist to I guess be even more of a pathetic loser than Les, and a kitten who managed to stowaway in Dan’s luggage.

Naturally though, a big part of this trip is Les continuing to make an ass out of himself to the annoyance of both the characters and the readers.

He also continues to whine once Kilimanjaro is pointed out to him and one begins to suspect even more that Summer and James are hoping that he doesn’t make it to the top with them.

Unfortunately for them Les just happens to be The Thing That Couldn’t Die so they’re left to deal with his childish whining.

“If by ‘there’ he means ‘Hell’ then we already are thanks to him.”

He also has trouble dealing with the altitude and thanks to Crazy Harry’s comic books begins hallucinating about Shanna the She-Devil and all the other white savior comic characters of yore.

As they approach the top, the group camps out in a snow storm and once it passes Les falls on his ass and Summer rightly laughs at him.

At the end of July, after a few more jokes at Dan’s expense, the group finally manages to make it to the summit.

Having reached the top it’s now time to make the trek back down. Thankfully Batty has the sense to not subject us to another entire month of Les being a pathetic annoyance and Dan being pathetically useless. But sadly, TB shows us that Les has decided not to respect Mother Earth by polluting one of her natural wonders with garbage.

Now she can harangue from the mountaintops.

Having made their way back, they all receive their certificate of authenticities and Les has to make one more terrible pun. It’s a wonder that James didn’t gut him and leave his rotting carcas in the jungle so the animals could choose to starve rather than eat his remains. Incredible restraint from this man.

Of course even on the way back home Les refuses to stop with his horseshit and Summer looks thoroughly finished with him as well.

“Seriously, can you lay off the puns for five seconds, Moby Dickhead?”

Once back at the Taj Moore-hal, the pair have a lot of interesting and insightful takeaways from their trip.

After another month or so of doofy stories about band camp, Pete’s imaginary battles with the Lord of the Late while his best friend and said friend’s wife move all of his stuff and Cory enlisting in the Army, we get a week dedicated to Les and Cayla moving their daughters’ stuff into their dorm. Summer wastes no time in telling Les to GTFO.

Only a week or so later she’s back in Westview to help with another Lisa’s Legacy unfun run. We get the first of the multiple instances of women coming to Les to tell them that his milking his wife’s death saved them from cancer too; all cribbed, as we’ve learned, from a similar experience Batty claims happened to him at a book signing.

As the wedding of Les and Cayla is occuring at basically the same time she manages to stick around for a little bit, getting death glared by everyone for an innocuous joke. Considering all she does for her dad, and by extension her about to be step-mother, and considering what she just had to put up with on a mountain half the world away Summer deserves a lame joke and not the judgemental stares of these losers.

With Les and Cayla married, Summer and Keisha get to cap things off as this multi-year storyline finally ends.

They also get one last appearance at the end of the year, riding the bench in what I’m pretty sure is the only instance we see of them playing basketball in college.

With that, we’ve reached what’s effectively the end of the first act of Act III. It’s very clear that TomBa had a general plot he wanted to carry him through the first few years of the post-Lisa’s death era of the strip and I will give him credit, he largely kept to it.

By this point Wally’s dealt with his PTSD and managed to start a new life with Rachel. Crazy Harry has reached his final form as with the post office closed he takes a job hanging around Komix Korner where I’m pretty sure he’ll die and then be stuffed and displayed like a taxidermied bear. Cory is now in the military and barring any Wallyesque incidents is on the path to straightening up. Darin and Jessica are now starting their life together in Westview. Summer has graduated. Les has remarried.

A lot of these were things set up very, very early in Act III and now five years later they’ve all been wrapped up with a nice, neat little bow. It’s an almost admirable bit of actual long term planning on Batiuk’s part and if he had just left it here with this being the ending of Funky Winkerbean… well, I don’t think it would be remembered as great but it would have left a better legacy I’m sure. Unfortunately there’s another decade left of this strip and it’s clear from this point on that any longterm plans Batty had have all been exhausted and we’re now in the “make it up as you go” stage of his writing.

This is, of course, best exemplified by Summer who for most of the next ten years is going to take a greatly reduced role in the story. Next time we’ll begin to take a look at just what life, and Batty, has in store for post-relevancy Summer.

Stop, Collaborate And Listen

My post from 9 days ago didn’t age well.

I bemoaned Tom Batiuk’s lack of ambition about his ambitionlessness, then he turns around and gives us his most ambitious ambitionless week yet.

This week is certainly trying to be something. And you don’t have to squint too hard to see what it is: a collection of noble statements about what America claims to be, juxtaposed with perceived current American realities.

A lot of commenters had great things to say about this week. Here’s the perfect place to start:

At no point has the conversation descended into arguments over politics. Though we all may have definite, even passionate, opinions on various political issues that are both compelling and well thought out, this isn’t an appropriate forum for that.

Y. Knott

To try and keep that tone, I will start by saying that I’m not here to talk about the rightness or wrongness of this week’s content. I’m here to talk about how well or poorly it is expressed. (You can probably guess which side I’m going to land on.)

Tom himself literally stated in the puff piece that he is not saying anything in the strips and is letting people make the commentary.

wherescrankshaft

Let’s dive into that puff piece! It is https://www.gocomics.com/extras/tom-batiuk-crankshaft-america-essay (hat tip to J.J. O’Malley).

Tom Batiuk Believes Comic Strips Can Do More Than Make Us Laugh

We’re not even past the headline yet, and it’s already obvious Batiuk wrote it.

As I said about Tom Batiuk’s interview with Terence Dollard awhile back: the people who interview Tom Batiuk do nothing but build strawmen out of softballs. One of Tom’s favorite notions is that he’s some kind of visionary for thinking comic strips don’t have to be funny. No one ever said they did! And some of the funniest strips are best remembered for their least funny moments.

From cancer to immigration, the “Crankshaft” creator has never shied away from difficult subjects.

OK, I’ll give him that.

For years, Tom Batiuk—creator of “Funky Winkerbean” and “Crankshaft”—has strived to expand the concept of a comic strip, challenging the idea that the art form is simply for laughs. This week’s “Crankshaft” storyline is a prime example: it uses recent news events to examine what it means to be an American today.

The center panel in four of the upcoming strips features a line of cursive handwriting plucked from a fictional essay written by Batiuk’s alter ego, cartoonist Batton Thomas, who we met back in the days of “Funky Winkerbean,” the comic Batiuk produced from 1972 to 2022. In one of the new strips, the line reads: “To me, America means home. A home where I feel safe and protected.”

In stark contrast, the very next panel features an illustration of Liam Conejo Ramos, the 5-year-old boy detained by ICE agents alongside his father in January 2026 outside their home in Columbia Heights, a Minneapolis suburb. Dressed in a bunny hat and Spider-Man backpack, the child was held with his father for nearly two weeks at a family detention center in Dilley, Texas. In a February interview with MPR News, his father said Liam continued to suffer from psychological trauma.

This sounds exactly like a high school essay, doesn’t it? The confident mastery of the obvious, the general air of pretentiousness, the tacked-on sentence clauses and irrelevant details.

Spider-Man backpack

Knowing what Tom Batiuk is really like, how important is that detail? If it was a Buzz Lightyear backpack, would Batiuk have ever learned of Ramos’ existence? He seems like the kind of guy who would have a Google News alert set up for the name of any comic book he thinks he should be the writer of.

The student essay by Batton Thomas in the “Crankshaft” strips echoes a real-life essay Batiuk wrote as a high school senior in 1965. He received an award from the local paper for the piece.

And now it has been written in a blog Tom Batiuk received an award and was written about in the newspaper. Will the next puff piece writer say “Batiuk has received an award and was written about in a newspaper and a blog”? Oh crap, now it’s a newspaper and two blogs.

A dream about that essay sparked the idea for the storyline, he says by phone

You heard it yourself, folks. Straight from the horse’s mouth. Tom Batiuk dreams about awards he won in high school 60 years ago. He said it. Not me.

In addition to young Liam Ramos, the images running this week include a masked ICE agent, the barbed wire fence outside an ICE detention center, and Jan. 6 rioters storming a barricade at the U.S. Capitol.

This article ran on Tuesday, and Batiuk just tipped off most of his shock moments for the upcoming week. And shock moments are all he has.

“The thing I like about the approach to this storyline,” Batiuk explains, “is that I don’t really say anything.

Same thing you’ve been doing for 25 years: not telling us anything. Just like you didn’t tell us where Eugene moved to or why. But you wrote two weeks of him saying goodbye slowly, and starting to go somewhere even more slowly.

I kind of left it to people to make their own decisions.

This is one of those things Batiuk likes to say about himself without really understanding it. He thinks it makes him sound noble, but he doesn’t realize how much his life’s work contradicts it. Tom Batiuk’s existence is a monument to his belief that all decisions should be made by him, or at least approved by him.

That doesn’t mean he’s not prepped for pushback—and he’s received plenty of that in his career.

Really? When? From who? Is he talking about that one time he got pulled from the Northern Wisconsin News over a joke that should have gotten him nationally roasted? Because it happened to Bobby Knight when he said a very similar thing.

Does he mean us? We don’t give pushback. We give thoughtful, critical analysis of his work. We don’t take him to task about his subject matter, except in his general choices of what to write about (“oh Lord, not another Batton Thomas week”).

Even Comics Curmudgeon rarely mentions his work anymore. And from what I’ve found on the Internet, genuine fans stopped bothering 15 years ago.

In his 54 years as a comic artist, Batiuk has used his strips to touch on thorny subjects such as teen suicide, book banning, capital punishment, and same-sex couples at the prom.

Again: I never said he didn’t try. However half-assed all four of those attempts were.

Six years ago, he penned a story arc in “Funky Winkerbean” about an Iraqi immigrant named Adeela seized by misguided ICE agents while delivering a pizza. She narrowly escaped deportation.

And we all know how she narrowly escaped deportation: by having Montoni’s ask Bill Clinton to do them a solid! During the first Trump administration. I wonder why the puff piece didn’t mention that.

Batiuk wrote himself into a corner, couldn’t write himself out, and then had to cover up his own incompetence in his own propaganda. Politics was this man’s true calling. North Korean politics.

Lisa Crawford-Moore

And here we are, folks! Somehow we went from real children and real American issues to Tom Batiuk’s Dollar Tree Lenore. Who’s been dead for 20 fucking years now. And who nobody ever really liked anyway.

But, in 2008, Batiuk was named a Pulitzer Prize finalist in editorial cartooning for this work, which is collected in the book Lisa’s Story: The Other Shoe.

10/10 no notes.

In “one of the best moments ever,” he says, he met a woman at a book signing…

You know how we always joke about there never being people at those book signings? Well, there’s your proof.

OK, I selectively quoted that to make a joke.

…who had read the strips and decided to get a mammogram.

Yet another real incident from Tom Batiuk’s life that ended up in the comic strip. Because of Lisa’s Story (available near you!) Marianne Winters discovered her own cancer, thanks to the great Les Moore! Marianne gave Les her Oscar Trophy, $1,000,000, a new car, the Pulitzer Prize, and a handjob.

Her doctors discovered a growth, which they safely removed. “I thought, wow, that’s all you can ask for from a comic strip,” Batiuk says.

It is unclear whether the growth or the comic strip was safely removed. I think they’re both equally toxic.

Batiuk is not the only comic strip artist to wrestle with challenging subject matter. Garry Trudeau used “Doonesbury”

Yes, let’s talk about Doonesbury, shall we? Let’s compare these two visionary cartoonists, since you’re trying to imply that Batiuk is on Trudeau’s level. Here’s how they each handled the same “difficult subject”:

Trudeau kept the gore offscreen to center the moment on the human emotion; Batiuk did the exact opposite. Keep in mind that Trudeau’s character is a soldier who would have been trained that limb loss was a possible outcome. Batiuk’s character was a high school girl who just won a prestigious music scholarship. Notice which one isn’t the least bit bothered. And which strip actually had a joke.

Notice also that Becky leads with “tell him I said hi”, as if her monumental act of forgiveness were the less important message. And the effects on her family were even less important! “Yeah, my mom’s a little bummed that I lost a 6-figure scholarship and a direct path to a prestigious career, and she’s suddenly gonna have to figure out how to pay for Kent Fucking State like everyone else in this craphole. But she’ll get over it.” And even a socially inept high school girlfriend on an ordinary day should have something more meaningful to say than “tell him I said hi.” Ugh.

the vast majority [of newspapers] do go along for the ride [by carrying controversial FW/CS strips]

Remember what I said about Batiuk being kicked out of the Northern Wisconsin News that one time? Thanks for proving my point. That joke was pretty accurate, wasn’t it?

And Mort Walker saddled Beetle Bailey with nightmares in 2013 to raise awareness of post-traumatic stress disorder.

The “Sarge beats Beetle into a puddle for no good reason” jokes sure haven’t stopped.

[comic strips] come right to your house. There’s no privilege whatsoever.

Just like ICE!

people see their lives reflected in [the characters]

Yeah. So did I once.

With or without the laughter.

Large bet on “without.”

Salt Farming

I been out of the loop for a few days, as harvest ratchets up to a fever pitch I haven’t had much time for anything else. I had read the dumb pumpkin patch Sunday strip, and then blithely ignored the internet for the next few days. But as I was taking wagons of soybeans into the elevator this afternoon I was musing over the next installment of my dumb fanfiction, and had decided to try to make an effort to work on it tonight.

I open up the blog, my GoComics, and BLAM! Right in my face! The turgid, forbidden, presence of that most verboten of blog topics: Politics.

You want to debate immigration reform vs enforcement? Go on over to GoComics and preach your gosh darn heart out. It’s what Batty and his entire crew are praying for, a little attention, a good old slap fight, a bit of salt pouring from peoples’ keyboards giving a shot of bitter flavor to Batiuk’s bland, white bread, existence.

Here let us all point and laugh at Batiuk for, once again, taking a serious issue and making it all about himself by tacking real world controversy to his 60-years-past high school achievement.

Let us ponder what the juxtaposition of past Les Moore panels in a story being narrated by Batton Thomas about his own history, and Batton claiming it’s a fictional representation of himself, means for the decaying logic of this entire Funkyverse. Remember Les Moore and Batton Thomas know each other! They’ve met multiple times!

Did they just have very similar experiences? Did Les Moore plagiarize Batton’s earlier essay? Did Batton include a fictional Les Moore into his fictional comic strip, based on the life of a real person he knew and presumably stalked after he noticed a similarity in their life experiences?

Is Batton so senile that he cannot tell his own memories from another’s? Does Batton secretly desire to BE Les Moore and fantasizes about taking over his life in a twisted Talented Mr. Ripley situation? Has he been stalking him his entire life, fictionalizing it all the while in a strip no one in the Funkyverse bothers to read?

Who really mixed up the scans of Lisa’s cancer that led to her treatment being interrupted for months? Someone who wanted to write about a writer writing about his dead wife and needed a ‘model’ to work off of?

Is this entire years long interview just an incredibly dedicated undercover operation where Skip seeks to expose Batton for the murder of Lisa Moore?

I promise an end to my stupid fanfic, just as soon as I stop being so mad at Batiuk for shoving politics in my safe space while I’ve been suffering through months of life in a battleground state. For Halloween I’m going as a Incredible Pulp made entirely of unsolicited political flyers. Does anyone else want to go as one? I’ve got enough of the darn things to outfit an entire parade of pulp monsters.

It’s The End Of The World As We Know It (And I Feel Fine)

Let’s face it: Tom Batiuk is giving us nothing to talk about anymore.

In What’s The Story, Morning Glory, I lamented the lack of any kind of actual story since Max and Hannah’s wedding in March. The two months since then have been more of the same: aimless filler weeks, tired Crankshaft tropes, and forced references to unloved latter-day topics like buck rub and the Winnipeg Blue Bombers.

I’ll let a recent comment get me started:

I almost feel like Crankshaft has to be ending next year.
It all feels like a man who’s reached the end of the flight and is (clumsily) getting ready to land the plane.

Narshe

I didn’t think this at first, but it’s getting harder to deny. I originally classified the tedious “In The Name Of The Father” as a non-story. But at least it was a Batiukian attempt at one: full of word zeppelins and pretentious award bait, signifying nothing. At least it was snark fodder. We’re not even getting that anymore. And his blog hasn’t mentioned any upcoming stories.

I’ll let Narshe continue:

We know [Batiuk] loves his anniversaries and 2027 contains a quite a few nice round(ish) numbered ones: 55 years since the debut of Funky Winkerbean, 40 years since the debut of Crankshaft, 30 years since he closed the book on John Darling by having Les solve his murder, 20 years since the death of Lisa, 10 years since Mopey met Mindy and 5 years since the end of FW. TomBa himself will also turn 80 next year.

This is all true. And if the awards-obsessed Batiuk hasn’t gotten his Golden T-Square by now, additional years aren’t going to get him one. (Though I still think he’s totally earned it.)

It’s hard to tell what’s going on in Tom Batiuk’s head. His own blog, and occasional mainstream news articles which he appears to write himself, have a very consistent tone. He presents his work as a combination of Charles Schulz and James Thurber: a cultural icon full of memorable, beloved characters, while also being a realistic literary look into the lives of downtrodden Ohioans. Except that “downtrodden” means “denied access to comic books” and “so passive they won’t lift a finger to solve their own problems.”

But man, it has to be taking a toll on his ego, especially considering how massive it is. It’s hard to keep doing something you think deserves a reward, and never getting that reward, and never even be mentioned for it anymore. The man peaked with that one Pulitzer nomination in 2008. And that second one is never coming.

I’m a generation younger than Tom Batiuk – I was born only two months after Funky Winkerbean was – and I can feel my own mortality starting to kick in. I also have a living parent who’s in their 80s now, and whose increasing limitations are obvious. Batiuk has to be noticing this in himself. And somebody has to be talking about it, if only his own wife, and other close friends who are going through the same thing.

I recently commented that Act IV (post-Funky Winkerbean) has now devolved into a gelatinous Act V. But I don’t think there’s a real reason to distinguish them. Crankshaft is still maintaining the low standard it’s had for decades; it hasn’t turned into Apartment 3-G, at least not any worse than it has been for years. The attempts at ambition are just fewer and farther between.

The end of the Funkyverse is now an inevitability. Even if it isn’t next year, it won’t be long after.