Thursday’s episode was not available for preview, but when has that ever stopped me? My assumption is that we’ve got more hand-wringing from Bull about changing jobs, but that’s not a given–to give him credit, Tom Batiuk can still be surprising, though rarely in a “Yay!” sort of way.
Commentator Bad Wolf found an interesting article yesterday about Funky Winkerbean in Variety. It’s already been discussed in Wednesday’s comments…
(Fun fact: I wrote most of this earlier in the day, and now pretty much all my points have been made in those aforementioned comments, but just like Tom Batiuk, I’m going to go ahead anyway, because I have nothing else!)
…but if you haven’t read it, take a glance; it’s an interesting read, though a very puzzling one. It’s puzzling because it reads as if the author has never actually read any examples of the actual strip, and is just summarizing press releases and Tom Batiuk panel appearances. In the first paragraph, Mr. Steinberg talks about Holly’s quest for comics and Les’ adventures in Hollywood…without mentioning how those stories played out. We’re told that Holly “searches fervently” for comic books, when in actual fact she was pretty much handed the damned things at every opportunity. Everyone else did the leg-work and just pointed her in a direction to find what she wanted. And we’re told that Les “grapples” with Hollywood producers over “Lisa’s Story.” I think the author mistyped “gripes,” since all Les ever did was whine and mope and be seen ostentatiously suffering. Whenever changes to the story were presented, Les just gasped and got the vapors, without ever arguing for his own vision. Les wanted to play the martyr, and all his energy went to that end.
At the end of the article, I was left feeling the way I do at the end of a Funky Winkerbean story–unsatisfied, with the nagging feeling that the author was capable, and playing with ideas that had potential, but then decided “the heck with this, I’m bored now” and just phoned it in. “Hey, Steinberg,” said the Editor in Chief, “comics are hot at the movies these days, and I read somewhere about this thing, Funky Winkerbean. Do a story and have it on my desk at 5:00.” It’s not that kind of comics, Steinberg thought, concealing his haughty superiority behind a hidden smirk. Then he began typing…
I will grant Mr. Steinberg his main point, which is that Funky Winkerbean is different from other comic strips. However, I will not grant the unspoken idea that “different” always equals “good,” or “better.” A pizza topped with chewing gum, cork, and rubber bands is different from every pizza you’ve ever seen. Do you want to eat it?