Where’s Crankshaft? No, Seriously, Where Is He?

This week has been about Jeff purchasing a sonic rodent control device, and annoying his family with it.

That’s right. Jeff. Not Ed Crankshaft, the character with a long history of purchasing esoteric devices, and annoying his family with them.

Why the hell is this a Jeff story? Jeff sucks. He’s the Bumbling Dad at best. In particular, he reminds me of Jerry Smith from Rick and Morty. And even Jerry Smith didn’t throw a tantrum over a missing t-shirt. Or nearly get his dumb ass killed in Bronson Canyon, and then bring home a rock as a gift for his wife.

But in the Funkyverse, Jeff can do no wrong. Why? Because Jeff is yet another Tom Batiuk stand-in. Batton Thomas, Pete Roberts-Reynolds, Les Moore, and Jeff Murdoch are all clones of Tom Batiuk, if he’d gone through different paths in life.

  • Batton is Cartoonist Tom Batiuk, close to the life Batiuk actually lived.
  • Pete is Comic Book Creator Tom Batiuk, living the life Batiuk thinks he’d be living if he’d had gotten that Marvel or DC job he wanted so badly. Because “the bullpen” totally exists, don’tcha know.
  • Les is Writer Tom Batiuk, constantly being flown to Hollywood to be praised, catered to, and grossly overpaid.
  • Les is also Teacher Tom Batiuk, full of condescension for the students he makes no effort to teach.
  • And Jeff is Regular Guy Tom Batiuk. Jeff exists not to show off one of the careers Batiuk thinks he should have had, but to show off how witty and clever Batiuk thinks he would be if he really were an ordinary sitcom dad.

Characters like Jerry Smith work, because the world responds to them believably. No other character has any respect for Jerry, and no other character should. He’s spineless, immature, and selfish, which causes problems for everyone else. When Jeff causes problems for everyone else, he acts like he just delivered the world’s greatest zinger. And nobody’s going to tell him otherwise.

This may be one of the worst one-week arcs in Funkyverse history, at least in the non-Batton Thomas division. And I pray to all things holy that this doesn’t go into week two. It demonstrates several recurring problems:

  • Ad hoc characterization. Ed should have been the driver of this story, not Jeff. Mindy shows up in the middle of it to be a punchline, even though she is now married to Pete, and wouldn’t be standing around her parents’ house to walk in on Ed’s Jeff’s shenanigans. Doesn’t she have a pizza restaurant to run?
  • Did not do the research. The human hearing range tops at a 20,000 hertz; mice can hear up to 70,000. No human being would be able to hear a sonic mouse control device, no matter how shrill the Bee Gees’ voices were. (And I don’t care how disco it is, “Stayin’ Alive” is an all-time banger.)
  • Self-defeating jokes. Building off the above, the central gag is about “age-related hearing loss”, which renders some people unable to hear the device. But somehow Jeff and Pam can’t hear the device, while Mindy (a generation younger) and Ed (a generation older) can. Ed’s hearing aid also facilitates it, which is not how hearing aids work. Then Jeff makes the lame joke “I’d rather listen to the Bee Gees while I still can”, even though he’s unable to hear the device. Which means he already has the age-related hearing loss, and wouldn’t be able to hear the Bee Gees anyway.
  • Failure to think ahead. If this is true, what else is true? If age related hearing loss makes you unable to hear the device, and also unable to hear the Bee Gees, that what would Bee Gees records sound like? Imagine any of their songs with all the high notes removed. It sounds like an AI slop joke, doesn’t it? “The Bee Gees, but you can’t hear anything above high E.” (The joke might be that it’s three minutes of silence, but that would still be a better joke than anything we’ve seen this week.)
  • Plot immunity for Mary Sues. Jeff is somehow immune to this magical age-related hearing loss, meaning the device won’t bother him like it does everyone else. So is Pam, but on the 19th and 21st this is packaged as female vanity. Tom Batiuk’s Mary Sue characters aren’t allowed to ever be wrong, or show any weaknesses. (Unless their weakness is something Batiuk thinks anyone in that position would have, such as being taunted by the Lord of the Late.)
  • Not having an ending. Several commenters thought Ed would redeem this arc with some last-second shenanigans, but that didn’t happen. Sunday’s strip was another lame throwback to an Act I trope: Montoni’s specialty pizzas. (Which nowadays, aren’t that different from what you can order at Casey’s.) And look! Mindy’s right back at work, smirking happily at Tony Montoni, who is apparently alive again.

These writing failures all overlap, and reinforce each other.

I’m on the record that “where’s Crankshaft?” isn’t a very good argument, because his presence doesn’t make the strip any better or worse. But Batiuk could at least put Crankshaft in the stories that center around his most common traits.

Unknown's avatar

Author: Banana Jr. 6000

Yuck. The fritos are antiquated.

2 thoughts on “Where’s Crankshaft? No, Seriously, Where Is He?”

  1. It’s a good thing that you mentioned the bullpen. The image in Batiuk’s mind must have been a physical location where he could hang out with cool people and sneer all over moms and sportos.

  2. Also, the poor goof cannot follow logic as that question never came up when Flash was using Isn’t Friction A Thing Speed to defeat Trickster.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.