(NOTE: This begins my retelling of The Burnings. It uses information from the real comic strips to tell a much different story. Think of it as an “alternate universe” version of The Burnings. Be aware that court transcripts do not include stage directions, or descriptions of how forcefully or quietly the defendants spoke, just what they said.)
BAILIFF: All rise for the Honorable Collis D. Smizer.
JUDGE: Please be seated. We begin with case 53766673. Ah, this is the criminal trial for the Village Booksmith fire. Prosecution, you may call your first witness.
(Nate Green, having sworn to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, testifies as follows:)
PROSECUTION: Please state your name for the record.
NATE: Nathaniel Green, but I go by Nate.
PROSECUTION: And you are the principal of Westview High School?
NATE: Yes.
PROSECUTION: And how long have you had that position?
NATE: I joined Westview High School in 1977 as a teacher, Al Burch retired in 1986, I was vice principal in 1988, and was principal by 2008.
PROSECUTION: Were you aware that Westview’s teacher Les Moore was teaching Fahrenheit 451 in class, even though this book was unapproved by the school board?
NATE: Yes.
PROSECUTION: Did you allow him to teach it?
NATE: No.
PROSECTION: Did you take any action to stop him from teaching it?
NATE: Yes. I specifically told him it wasn’t approved to order, and that meant “not approved to teach.”
PROSECUTION: What did you do when you discovered he was teaching the book anyway?
NATE: Nothing.
PROSECUTION: Why not?
NATE: Because I can’t do anything to Les Moore. For some reason, he’s got some kind of protected status in this community. I don’t dare discipline him. I get that he’s famous because of Lisa’s Story, but he’s honestly an awful teacher. He’s basically a tenured professor, and he knows it. I couldn’t even get rid of him when we had layoffs.
PROSECUTION: How is he an ineffective teacher?
NATE: Have you interviewed the guy yet? He’s elitist, condescending to his students, thinks he’s God’s gift to writing because of that book, wastes class time on pointless speakers he likes, and disappears for months at a time. One time he used his students to wage an in-school media war against me about copier usage, and I couldn’t do a damn thing about it.
PROSECUTION: You couldn’t discipline him for that?
NATE: No. The school board said it would “upset the community.” The same school board he’s defying now.
PROSECUTION: You said he missed months at a time? You couldn’t discipline him for missing too many work days?
NATE: Oh, get this. Every time Les didn’t want to go to work, he took bereavement leave. He found out the school board never put a time limit on it, so he just kept mourning Lisa for decades. Then when it was time to make the movie, he spent months in Hollywood because he had a huge number of sick days saved up. Again, the same school board he’s defying now.
PROSECUTION: Did you know that Mr. Moore had instructed his students to pick up the books at Booksmellers, and later The Village Booksmith?
NATE: Well, he didn’t tell me, but you know, it’s high school. Kids talk, word gets around.
PROSECUTION: Did Mr. Moore say anything to you about this plan?
NATE: Of course not.
PROSECUTION: Did any parents contact you with concerns about the book being taught in class?
NATE: No.
PROSECUTION: What did you think when you heard about the Booksmellers fire?
NATE: I didn’t really believe it. It seemed far-fetched. Fahrenheit 451 is not an offensive book. It’s not the kind of book anybody would burn in protest. At the time, I thought maybe the fire was unrelated.
PROSECUTION: And what about the second fire?
NATE: Well, after the second fire, the school board called me in for a meeting. I guess they didn’t believe the first fire either.
PROSECUTION: What did you say?
NATE: Well, technically Les was right. The book wasn’t approved to order, and he didn’t order it. So he didn’t really do anything they could punish him for. I just told the board he did this without my permission or approval, which was true.
PROSECUTION: So Mr. Moore openly defied you and the school board?
NATE: Well, he found a loophole, but he knew he was defying their wishes. He gave me this smug speech about the list not being clear.
PROSECUTION: Did he ever say why he chose to teach the book when the list implicitly forbade it?
NATE: Hmm. He didn’t, now that you mention it. You know what else he did, though? This one time–
PROSECUTION: –okay, thank you, Mr. Green.

